Kwikset Halo Select vs Kwikset SmartCode 917 Keypad Smart Lock: Which one is better?

Kwikset Halo Select is more advanced of the two locks, combining several wireless technologies into one connected deadbolt

When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Here’s how it works.

An undated image of Kwikset Halo Select Smart Lock. — Kwikset
An undated image of Kwikset Halo Select Smart Lock. — Kwikset

Smart locks come in many forms, from fully connected models with Wi-Fi to straightforward keypad locks that operate completely offline. 

The Kwikset Halo Select and Kwikset SmartCode 917 both represent these two different approaches.

The Halo Select is built for modern smart homes, offering Wi-Fi, Matter, Thread, Bluetooth, and compatibility with major platforms, while the SmartCode 917 focuses on simple, dependable keyless access without apps, wireless connectivity, or smart-home hubs.

Kwikset Halo Select vs SmartCode 917 Keypad Smart Lock specs

FeatureKwikset Halo Select Keypad Smart Lock  Kwikset SmartCode 917 Keypad Smart Lock
Lock type Touchscreen smart deadbolt Keypad electronic lever lock

Connectivity

Wi-Fi, Matter, Thread, BluetoothNone

User capacity

Not specified

Up to 30 codes

Keypad

Backlit touchscreen 

 Backlit keypad

Auto-lock

YesYes

Physical key

YesYes

SmartKey Security

Not specifiedYes
Best dealsKwikset Halo Select Keypad Smart Lock Kwikset SmartCode 917 Keypad Smart Lock

Kwikset Halo Select Smart Lock

The Kwikset Halo Select is the more advanced of the two locks, combining several wireless technologies into one connected deadbolt.

Pros

  1. Matter 1.2 support for broad smart-home compatibility
  2. Wi-Fi, Thread, and Bluetooth connectivity
  3. Works with Apple Home, Alexa, Google Home, and SmartThings
  4. Touchscreen keypad for convenient PIN entry

Cons

  1. No fingerprint scanner
  2. Thread requires compatible infrastructure
  3. Higher price

Kwikset SmartCode 917 Keypad Lever Lock

The Kwikset SmartCode 917 takes a much simpler approach. Rather than offering Wi-Fi or smart-home connectivity, it focuses on providing reliable keyless entry through a backlit keypad and physical key.

Pros

  1. Up to 30 user codes
  2. SmartKey Security
  3. Adjustable auto-lock functionality
  4. Backlit keypad makes nighttime entry easier
  5. Suitable for lever-operated doors

Cons

  1. No Wi-Fi or Bluetooth
  2. No smartphone app or remote unlocking
  3. No smart-home integration

Which Kwikset smart lock should you buy?

The Kwikset Halo Select is the clear choice if you want a modern connected smart lock. Its Matter support, Wi-Fi, Thread, Bluetooth, smartphone control, and compatibility with multiple smart-home ecosystems make it considerably more versatile.

Meanwhile, the Kwikset SmartCode 917 is better for users who don't need remote access or smart-home automation.